MVSFORUMS.com

[krkcs]

I dont know if anyone is aware of the APS Programs. APS programs are some tool generated programs, they are very difficult one's to get analysed and fixed.
I'm not sure if there is any tool that exists, which would convert the APS programs to the equivalent structured COBOL programs, which are pretty much easier to be maintained ?

Can anyone throw some light on this ?

Suggestions/ Directions are appreciated...
_________________
-kr

[dbzTHEdinosauer]

That is the problem with 'tool' generated code............it is generated via parms. Your input definitions - files, databases, mapping of fields - what to what, and processing conditions. The input is structured - by the tool - so that the tool can generate the code. I have found that sometimes the structured definitions forces you to change your design.
Actually, that is the problem. you are not allowed to impose your design on the code. That's probably one reason that there are no 'conversion tools' to take this spaghetti and make good pasta (modular).

Modular code is an art, and starts at design. My experiences (only twice, i will never take on a project like that again!) required dedicated design and we ended up just rippin' and strippin' what we needed to create the new modules - then threw it away - actually one customer sold this garbage to someone else to finance the conversion costs.

IMUO:
Tool generated code has it's place, but I don't think that the place is generating code for complex processes - simple stuff yes - like if you bought the tool and did not buy ezytrieve; but not in a shop where you have quality designers and programmers.

good luck!




Try google.
_________________
Dick Brenholtz
American living in Varel, Germany

[JanM]

In my opinion you should never try to 'fix' generated code.
If there is a problem, solve it at the input for the generator proces.
Two reasons:
a) A new run of the generator will generate new source code without the fix, so you mist re-apply the fix, but you can't be sure that the old fix fits.
b) When you look at the input of the generate proces, it does not describe the actions that are being performed.
_____________
Jan Meijer